NepalEnergyForum

NEA to Float Fresh Tender After NTPC Refuses to Supply Electricity at Previous Rate

Kathmandu: Energy entrepreneurs have expressed strong opposition to the government’s plan to introduce new criteria for Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), arguing that the proposed framework could undermine the private sector.

The opposition follows the government’s move to introduce criteria that entrepreneurs say would restrict private-sector participation in hydropower development.

The executive committee meeting of the Independent Power Producers’ Association, Nepal (IPPAN) has decided not to accept the proposed framework.

According to IPPAN President Mohan Kumar Dangi, the draft PPA framework is anti-private sector.

“If this draft is implemented, even a 1 MW project will not be able to secure a PPA. We will meet the Energy Minister and present our concerns. We will protest,” he said. “This is not something that needs to be amended; it must be rejected. There cannot be two different laws for government and private-sector projects. No one can introduce rules simply according to their wishes. The framework must be scrapped. If it is introduced in a way that destroys the sector, we will either have to leave IPPAN or protest against it.”

The proposed framework reportedly allows PPAs for government-owned projects while restricting agreements with private-sector projects. IPPAN has also argued that the framework has been introduced with the intention of avoiding purchases of electricity generated by private-sector projects during the wet season, which it says is both unfair and illegal.

What Does the Proposed PPA Framework Contain?

The government has proposed sweeping changes to the criteria for signing Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) with private-sector hydropower projects.

The new draft framework, prepared with the stated objective of making the PPA process objective, transparent and financially sustainable, proposes that obtaining a generation licence and signing a grid connection agreement will no longer automatically entitle a project to a PPA.

Under the proposed PPA Framework, projects will be evaluated based on their contribution to the national power system, dry-season electricity generation, capacity to meet evening peak demand, availability of transmission infrastructure, construction readiness and the risks assumed by developers.

According to the proposed criteria, projects seeking PPAs will be evaluated in three stages.

In the first stage, projects will undergo a minimum eligibility test. Those that qualify will be assessed in the second stage against a total of 100 points and classified into categories A, B, C and D. In the third stage, projects will be selected within the annual PPA procurement limit determined by the Nepal Electricity Authority (NEA).

Rather than signing PPAs with all projects capable of generating electricity, the proposed system seeks to prioritise projects that meet the requirements of the national power system, can reliably transmit their electricity and fall within the NEA’s financial capacity.

PPA Selection in Three Stages

Under the first stage of the proposed framework, projects must meet minimum mandatory eligibility requirements. Projects that fail to fulfil legal, technical, grid-related and financial prerequisites will not be allowed to participate in the second-stage points-based evaluation.

In the second stage, projects meeting the minimum requirements will be evaluated against six major criteria, carrying a total of 100 points.

The highest allocation, 30 points, has been assigned to system value and contribution. Another 30 points have been allocated to transmission infrastructure and grid readiness.

Similarly, 25 points have been allocated to risk allocation and PPA structure, five points to project readiness, five points to climate resilience and multipurpose utility, and five points to strategic and regional importance.

Under this evaluation system, a project’s electricity generation capacity alone will not be sufficient. Its ability to supply electricity during the dry season, generate power during evening peak-demand hours, connect to the national transmission system and demonstrate construction readiness will also be decisive factors.

In the third stage, the NEA will determine an annual PPA procurement limit. The proposed framework requires this limit to take into account the maximum capacity available for new PPAs, project construction timelines, the maximum amount of energy that can be contracted, the maximum Take-or-Pay exposure and the NEA’s annual PPA payment obligations.

Six Minimum Eligibility Requirements for PPAs

Under the proposed framework, projects applying for PPAs must meet six minimum eligibility requirements.

First, a project must possess a valid electricity generation licence issued under prevailing laws. The proposed framework states that conditions in the generation licence that could obstruct project construction or operation will not be acceptable.

Second, if a project is located within a national park, conservation area or protected area, it must obtain a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Ministry of Agriculture, Forests and Environment. Projects located in such areas must also have secured the necessary construction permits and approvals.

Third, a project must have an updated and valid Grid Connection Agreement (GCA) that remains effective until the date of signing the PPA. The agreement must not contain provisions that would normally result in overloading of internal transmission lines.

Fourth, the project must ensure that the necessary transmission infrastructure will be available by its Required Commercial Operation Date (RCOD). For this purpose, an agreement for the construction of the transmission infrastructure required to evacuate the project’s electricity must already have been signed.

Fifth, at least 30 percent of the project’s total energy generation must be guaranteed during the dry season.

Sixth, the proposed PPA must not create an unacceptable financial liability for the Nepal Electricity Authority. The agreement must also be consistent with the NEA’s decisions. In addition, PPA proposals must be submitted exclusively in Nepali currency.

Projects failing to meet these minimum requirements will not be eligible to enter the points-based classification process.

System Contribution Receives the Highest Allocation of 30 Points

The proposed criteria make system value and contribution the most important factors in PPA selection, allocating 30 points to this category.

Points will be awarded based on the type and system value of the project, its share of dry-season energy, evening peak-generation capacity during the dry season, verified peaking duration and project development model.

Five points have been allocated to project type and system value.

Under the proposed criteria, storage hydropower and pumped-storage projects will receive five points. Peaking Run-of-River (PRoR) and semi-reservoir projects will receive four points.

Projects combining Run-of-River (RoR) hydropower with solar and a Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) will receive three points, while RoR projects combined with BESS will receive two points. Conventional RoR projects will receive one point.

This arrangement appears to give greater priority to storage, semi-storage and energy-storage-based projects than conventional river-flow projects in terms of their usefulness to the power system.

Rather than selecting projects solely based on their annual electricity generation, the NEA intends to encourage projects that can provide firm energy, flexibility and balancing capacity required by the national grid.

Projects Supplying More Dry-Season Electricity to Receive 10 Points

A total of 10 points have been allocated to the verified share of energy available during the dry season. Projects capable of supplying a higher proportion of dry-season electricity will receive more points.

Under the proposed criteria, projects with a verified dry-season energy share of 30 to 34.99 percent will receive four points. Those with 35 to 39.99 percent will receive six points, while projects with 40 to 44.99 percent will receive eight points. Projects with a dry-season energy share of 45 percent or more will receive 10 points.

However, the dry-season energy share will not be determined solely on the basis of developers’ self-declarations or claims. The availability of such energy must be established through independent hydrological studies and verification.

The proposed framework also includes additional penalties if a project fails to supply the dry-season energy committed under the PPA.

If a project cannot deliver the contracted dry-season energy, it will have to pay a penalty equivalent to 150 percent of the applicable purchase rate for the energy shortfall.

The framework also prohibits developers from including a portion of their wet-season generation in their dry-season energy estimates simply to show a higher dry-season energy share.

Priority for Projects Capable of Meeting Evening Peak Demand

The proposed framework also places importance on a project’s ability to manage evening peak demand during the dry season. Five points have been allocated for this criterion.

Points will be awarded based on the verified capacity a project can supply during periods of peak demand in the dry season.

Projects capable of supplying less than 50 percent of their capacity during this period will receive one point. Those capable of supplying 50 to 75 percent will receive three points, while projects able to supply 75 percent or more will receive five points.

The project’s total installed capacity and minimum monthly average generation capacity during the dry season will be the main considerations.

Similarly, a project’s peaking capacity and duration must be independently verified. Peaking capacity will be determined through the project’s design, hydrological studies, calculations of reservoir or pondage capacity and an independent technical review.

Projects with a peaking duration of less than two hours will receive zero points. Those capable of peaking for two to four hours will receive one point, four to six hours will receive three points, and more than six hours will receive five points.

The objective is to prioritise projects that can not only generate electricity during the dry season but also supply power according to demand during evening peak hours.

Projects in the Same River System Also Given Priority

Five points have been allocated to the project development model. Under this criterion, projects located downstream of existing reservoir-based projects within the same hydrological system will receive higher scores.

Projects located downstream of existing reservoir-based projects will receive five points. Those located downstream of reservoir projects under construction will receive four points.

Projects located downstream of existing PRoR projects will receive three points, while those located downstream of PRoR projects under construction will receive two points.

Similarly, projects developed in a cascade system with existing RoR projects will receive one point, while projects located downstream of existing RoR projects will receive zero points.

Here, the term downstream area refers to a maximum of two projects located downstream of the reference project.

Transmission Infrastructure Readiness Also Carries 30 Points

The proposed PPA evaluation system allocates another 30 points to transmission infrastructure and grid readiness. This criterion will prioritise whether the electricity generated by a project can actually be connected to the national transmission system.

Under the proposed criteria, an existing transmission line without power-flow restrictions will receive 30 points.

An existing transmission line with an N-1 power-flow restriction will receive 20 points.

Similarly, a transmission line under construction without power-flow restrictions will receive 30 points, while one under construction with an N-1 power-flow restriction will receive 20 points.

Projects relying on proposed or planned transmission lines for which construction contracts have not yet been signed will receive only 10 points.

Under the framework, a transmission line will be considered under construction only after its construction contract has been signed. Such transmission infrastructure must also be operational before the hydropower project begins commercial production.

This provision aims to reduce the risks associated with signing PPAs for projects without certainty regarding the availability of transmission infrastructure.

Construction-Ready Projects to Receive Five Points

Five points have been allocated to project readiness. The objective is to prioritise projects that are genuinely prepared to begin construction rather than those that have obtained licences but have yet to complete the necessary procedures.

Under the proposed criteria, projects that have received land-use approval will receive two points. Those that have obtained tree-felling approval will receive an additional two points, while projects that have completed financial arrangements will receive one point.

Projects that have completed the necessary land, forest-clearance and financial arrangements can therefore secure the full five points.

Incentives for Climate-Resilient and Multipurpose Projects

Five points have also been allocated to climate resilience and multipurpose utility.

Projects designed to withstand climate-related challenges will receive three points, while multipurpose projects will receive two points.

The provision is expected to encourage developers to incorporate measures addressing potential risks arising from climate change into project development.

Projects Assuming Greater Wet-Season Electricity Risks to Receive 25 Points

The new framework allocates 25 points to risk allocation and PPA structure.

Under this criterion, projects will be awarded points based on the percentage of wet-season electricity covered by Take-or-Pay obligations.

According to the proposed provisions, projects offering an 80 percent Take-or-Pay arrangement for wet-season energy will receive 10 points. Those offering 70 percent will receive 15 points, 60 percent will receive 20 points, and 50 percent or less will receive 25 points.

This means projects in which developers assume a greater share of the electricity sales and payment risks associated with wet-season generation will receive higher scores.

The proposed framework also requires a minimum of 20 percent of wet-season energy to be retained as a reserve margin when signing PPAs. Developers will not be allowed to propose arrangements that differ from this provision.

The Take-and-Pay energy committed by developers will be incorporated into the PPA as a reserve margin.

If developers wish, they will be allowed to export this energy to international markets through the Nepal Electricity Authority or its subsidiary, Nepal Power Trading Company Limited (NPTCL).

However, developers will have to bear the applicable transmission charges and trading margins for such electricity exports.

Projects in Karnali to Receive the Highest Regional Priority

The proposed PPA criteria will also evaluate projects based on their strategic and regional importance. Five points have been allocated to this category.

Based on geographical location, projects to be developed in Karnali Province will receive five points.

Projects in Madhesh Province will receive four points, those in Lumbini and Sudurpashchim provinces will receive three points each, while projects in other provinces will receive one point.

Points will be awarded based on the province in which a project’s powerhouse is located.

This provision indicates an intention to give additional priority to energy project development in Karnali, Madhesh, Lumbini and Sudurpashchim provinces.

Up to 20 Points Can Be Deducted Based on Developers’ Past Performance

The new framework also incorporates developers’ past performance into the project evaluation process.

To improve the certainty of project implementation, the proposal includes negative marking of up to 20 points.

Five points will be deducted if a survey or generation licence is found to have been transferred or traded.

If the shareholders or shareholding structure existing at the time of obtaining the survey licence changes by 25 to 50 percent, two points will be deducted. A change of more than 50 percent will result in a deduction of three points.

Similarly, five points will be deducted if significant inconsistencies are found in technical data or if incorrect information is submitted.

Another five points will be deducted if a developer proposes to change the project’s capacity after the generation licence has been issued.

These provisions seek to discourage developers from obtaining licences merely to hold projects, delaying construction for extended periods, failing to meet contractual obligations or engaging in the trading of licences.

Projects to Be Classified into Categories A, B, C and D After 100-Point Evaluation

Projects that meet the minimum eligibility requirements and participate in the evaluation process will be classified into four categories based on their scores.

Score      Category       PPA arrangement

80–10       A                 Priority for PPA

65–79       B                 PPA subject to conditions

50–64       C                  Deferred for the time being

Below50    D                  No PPA

Projects scoring between 80 and 100 points will be placed in Category A and given priority for PPAs.

Projects scoring between 65 and 79 points will fall under Category B. Such projects may receive PPAs subject to conditions if capacity remains available within the annual procurement limit after agreements have been signed with Category A projects.

The proposed arrangement also requires such projects to be given time to complete the necessary improvements to qualify for Category A before the conditional PPA arrangement is applied.

Projects scoring between 50 and 64 points will be classified under Category C, and their PPAs will be deferred for the time being.

If capacity remains available within the annual procurement limit, these projects may be given time to make the necessary improvements to qualify for Category A and undergo re-evaluation.

Projects scoring below 50 points will fall under Category D and will not be eligible for PPAs.

However, even projects classified under Category A will not automatically receive the right to a PPA. Agreements will have to be consistent with the requirements of the national power system, available transmission capacity and the NEA’s financial capacity. The final decision-making authority will remain with the NEA.

The proposed framework also states that if the total capacity of Category A projects exceeds the annual approved PPA procurement limit, not all projects in that category will automatically receive agreements.

If the combined Take-or-Pay capacity of Category A projects exceeds the annual approved PPA limit, projects will be selected through an additional competitive scoring process.

The selection will be based on risk allocation, dry-season energy, evening peak-generation contribution during the dry season, project readiness and system value.

Projects will be ranked according to their scores under these criteria. Selection will begin with the highest-scoring project and continue until the annual approved PPA limit is reached.

If the NEA cannot purchase the entire capacity of the final selected project, it may offer a PPA for only a portion of its capacity.

This arrangement seeks to introduce competition even among projects in the same category, based on their actual contribution to the power system and their ability to assume risks.

Separate Annual PPA Limit for Projects Up to 10 MW

The proposed framework also covers small hydropower projects with capacities of up to 10 MW. However, it does not propose extensive exemptions from the PPA policy for such projects.

A separate annual PPA procurement limit will be determined for projects of up to 10 MW. Projects will then be selected for PPAs using the same evaluation method outlined above.

For PPAs with small hydropower projects, the main considerations will include a valid generation licence and Grid Connection Agreement, the quantity of electricity that the relevant distribution or transmission network can reliably absorb and transmit, assurance that no additional investment in the transmission or distribution system will be required, and compliance with climate-resilience criteria.

The proposed framework also seeks to prioritise projects with assured local consumption or transmission arrangements and those located on rivers with fewer hydropower projects.

It also requires assured data integration with the Load Dispatch Centre.

NEA to Determine Annual PPA Procurement Limits

Under the proposed provisions, the Nepal Electricity Authority will have to approve an annual PPA procurement limit for each fiscal year.

For hydropower projects above 10 MW, the NEA will have to determine the maximum Take-or-Pay PPA capacity and the timeline within which projects covered by such agreements must begin commercial production.

Similarly, a separate maximum Take-or-Pay PPA capacity and commercial operation timeline will have to be determined for hydropower projects of up to 10 MW.

This will provide the NEA with a basis for determining in advance how much electricity it will purchase annually, how many projects it will sign agreements with and the financial liabilities that will arise from those agreements.

Capacity Upgrades to Receive PPAs Only Under Take-and-Pay Arrangements

The proposed framework includes separate provisions for hydropower projects that have already signed PPAs and subsequently propose to increase their generation capacity through upgrading.

Such projects may be allowed to sign a PPA once under a Take-or-Pay arrangement for dry-season energy and a Take-and-Pay arrangement for wet-season energy.

However, projects that have signed PPAs under the new framework or after its implementation and subsequently propose additional capacity upgrades will be allowed to enter into agreements only under Take-and-Pay provisions.

This appears to be aimed at preventing additional long-term purchase obligations from being created in the name of capacity expansion.

Generation Licences and Grid Agreements Will No Longer Guarantee PPAs

One of the most significant policy changes in the proposed framework is that a generation licence and a grid connection agreement will no longer be treated as automatic entitlements to a PPA.

The draft framework describes a PPA as a long-term contractual commitment made by the NEA. Electricity will be purchased only when it is clearly necessary for the national power system, can be reliably supplied, is economically justified and is financially sustainable.

The NEA has proposed moving away from signing PPAs solely on the basis of a project’s electricity generation potential.

Instead, electricity will be purchased only after ensuring that a project meets the overall demand requirements of the power system, can reliably transmit and supply electricity, provides measurable system contributions and does not create unacceptable long-term financial liabilities for the authority.

The proposed framework states that its objective is not to halt private-sector hydropower development but to change the existing basis on which electricity purchase agreements are signed.

It aims to continue encouraging private-sector electricity generation while protecting the NEA from excessive long-term contractual financial risks.

In particular, the new criteria seek to direct private investment towards reservoir-based projects, projects capable of generating more electricity during the dry season, projects that can meet evening peak demand, projects compatible with available transmission infrastructure and those that can make a tangible contribution to strengthening Nepal’s energy security.

 

Nepalpurbadhar